Skip to main content

Search hotels in Sister Bay

Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Sister Bay hotels

Filter by:


Star rating

Review score

Sister Bay – 6 hotels and places to stay

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Open Hearth Lodge, hotel in Sister Bay

Featuring an indoor pool and hot tub, Open Hearth Lodge is located in Door County’s Sister Bay. The town centre and access to Lake Michigan are 3 minutes’ drive away. Free WiFi access is available.

Breakfast really makes this an affordable vacation. Saves a lot of time and money.
9.2
Scored 9.2
Superb
Rated superb
578 reviews
Price fromISK 17,670per night
Pheasant Park Resort, hotel in Sister Bay

Set in Sister Bay and with Sister Bay Beach reachable within less than 1 km, Pheasant Park Resort offers a shared lounge, allergy-free rooms, free WiFi throughout the property and barbecue facilities....

No breakfast. Good location!
9.2
Scored 9.2
Superb
Rated superb
127 reviews
Price fromISK 24,863per night
Country House Resort, hotel in Sister Bay

Featuring an outdoor pool and tennis court, Country House Resort is located in Sister Bay. This adult-oriented accommodation offers fishing, cycling and hiking facilities.

The renovations made on the suite were phenomenal! The view of the lake was unobstructed and beautifully framed. Randall at the front desk was gracious enough to wait for us beyond the 8:00 closing. Instructions to the suite and all the amenities in the room were explicit. Loved the availability of channels and WIFI. The box of chocolate was nummy. Winter breakfast can be taken from the front desk area and brought back to the unit. Selections had enough variety and were of good quality. Coffee pods were also wonderfully robust and rich-my preference.
9.3
Scored 9.3
Superb
Rated superb
285 reviews
Price fromISK 17,982per night
Birchwood Lodge, hotel in Sister Bay

Set in Sister Bay, 700 metres from Sister Bay Beach, Birchwood Lodge offers accommodation with free bikes, free private parking, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness centre.

9.0
Scored 9.0
Superb
Rated superb
5 reviews
Price fromISK 20,680per night
Sister Bay Inn, hotel in Sister Bay

Set in Sister Bay, 1.3 km from Sister Bay Beach, Sister Bay Inn offers accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a fitness centre and a garden.

The owners are fantastic and welcoming and the common area for food is clean and well stocked. The grounds / facilities are great.
8.8
Scored 8.8
Fabulous
Rated fabulous
310 reviews
Price fromISK 25,688per night
The Nordic Lodge, hotel in Sister Bay

Boasting a tranquil location in the woods of Door County, this Sister Bay, Wisconsin lodge features an indoor pool and a hot tub. Free WiFi access is available throughout the property.

Didn't participate in breakfast. Had plans with groups. The lower door was very handy for room access.
7.6
Scored 7.6
Good
Rated good
519 reviews
Price fromISK 23,882per night
Bay Breeze Resort, hotel in Sister Bay

Set in Ephraim, 18 km from Cana Island Lighthouse, Bay Breeze Resort offers accommodation with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking, a garden and a private beach area.

Very comfortable & quiet.
9.2
Scored 9.2
Superb
Rated superb
265 reviews
Price fromISK 23,299per night
The Water Street Inn, hotel in Sister Bay

The Water Street Inn is situated in Ephraim. All rooms offer a view of the water. Along with complimentary bikes, the property features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool. Free WiFi is featured.

This was a wonderful getaway! We appreciated the staff immensely. They were kind, and helpful, including when we locked ourselves out, they came from Jackson Port to unlock our door!
9.2
Scored 9.2
Superb
Rated superb
124 reviews
Price fromISK 44,061per night
Parkwood Lodge, hotel in Sister Bay

The Door County Parkwood Lodge offers many activities, including a tennis court. It offers free WiFi access and is 1.5 km away from Peninsula State Park.

We have stayed there many times. Great location for us, centrally located. Close to Peninsula State Park and downtown Fish Creek. In the middle of Door County. Nice size room. (king suite) Comfortable bed for both of us, I like a soft bed and my wife likes a firm bed.
8.3
Scored 8.3
Very good
Rated very good
588 reviews
Price fromISK 16,814per night
Ephraim Shores Resort, hotel in Sister Bay

Set in Ephraim, 17 km from Cana Island Lighthouse, Ephraim Shores Resort offers accommodation with a fitness centre, free private parking, a garden and a terrace.

We have stayed he numerous tomes n we choose it for our 45 th wedding anniversary.
8.9
Scored 8.9
Fabulous
Rated fabulous
190 reviews
Price fromISK 24,706per night
See all 8 hotels in Sister Bay

Most booked hotels in Sister Bay in the past month

What guests said about Sister Bay:

  • 10
    Scored 10

    I am hoping the mold in the bathroom was a temporary thing.

    I am hoping the mold in the bathroom was a temporary thing. On the plus side they did have a dehumidifier in the room and that made me feel better. I would stay here again and I would highly recommend it for so many other reasons. In their defense. It was a very humid summer in the area and the mold very well. Could have been from that or from someone taking way too long of a shower
    A
    Anonymous
    United States
  • 10
    Scored 10

    Sister bay is easy to get around in just driving or walking...

    Sister bay is easy to get around in just driving or walking on 42. The marina, beach and boat tours are favorite things to do. Lure restaurant is a great place to dine for seafood. For grocery shopping, Piggly Wiggly is where you want to go, located on 42 in the Country Walk Shops. To gas up your vehicle, the BP station is just across the road from there.
    Wayne & Linda C
    United States
  • 8.0
    Scored 8.0

    The best relaxing getaway!

    The best relaxing getaway! We ate at the Summer Kitchen, the Sister Bay bowling alley (yes, very nice and very good!) and a little hangout place for lunch/snack called, Not Licked Yet. Sister Bay is so centrally located that parks and other towns are all close. One of the nicest little vacations we've had if you enjoy a step back in time and some peace and tranquility. There's also a nice little dog park in Ephraim and our dog enjoyed the trip as much as we did!
    A
    Anonymous
  • 10
    Scored 10

    Location is in the middle of it all, great shops and food...

    Location is in the middle of it all, great shops and food along the way.Al Johnson’s is a must to eat at. The live music outside in warmer weather is enjoyable as is sitting in the park watching the children play on the playground and watching the boaters on the lake. We picked Sister Bay for our mom’s memorial bench because she/us loved it here
    Linda
    United States
  • 4.0
    Scored 4.0

    Well, breakfast is from 7 AM to 9 AM every morning.

    Well, breakfast is from 7 AM to 9 AM every morning. When on vacation who is up before 9:00 to go for breakfast? The second morning there was no breakfast at all! Evidently, we were told, that food truck didn’t come in! Wow that’s there was no breakfast or anything in the lounge Now they know how many people are going to be staying in that hotel, which I believe was full. So wouldn’t you order extra food for breakfast in case something happened like that, meaning the food truck did not come in!
    A
    Anonymous
    United States
  • 10
    Scored 10

    We found the perfect hotel in Sister Bay at Country House...

    We found the perfect hotel in Sister Bay at Country House and enjoy all the options for food and entertainment in town. This was our 3rd year in a row and we can't wait to return. We prefer going in September when the weather is still nice but it's less crowded.
    Rosemarie
    United States

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Sister Bay

  • 9.2
    Scored 9.2
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 578 reviews
    John and his staff always do their best to meet the needs of their guests. This was our 2nd stay at OHL and we have never overheard anything but good things amongst the guests. The location is perfect to access all areas of Door County and the breakfast has something for everyone. We love the gas firepits outside, they are perfect for winding down after a busy day. We will always stay here when we visit. It meets all of our needs.
    William
    United States
  • 10
    Scored 10
    Exceptional
    Rated exceptional
     · 1 review
    Everything about our stay was absolutely wonderful. Erin and John are the most attentive, welcoming hosts. It was so easy to communicate with them. Their home is so, so beautiful. Their attention to detail is unparalleled. We had the best time vacationing at their Sister Bay Haus. It is so convenient to many, many activities and restaurants. If given the opportunity , you should book this home- you will not be disappointed.
    Diana
    United States
  • 8.6
    Scored 8.6
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 276 reviews
    A great place to stay and we will definitely return. The full kitchen was perfect since you can easily spend $40 or $50 just for breakfast in a place like Sister Bay. Two bedrooms, 3 TVs, excellent WIFI, Super clean. Even a balcony to relax with a glass of wine after fighting Door County traffic. And since it's secluded in the woods with its own parking you don't have the parking problems of Fish Creek and Sister Bay.
    Gerald Todd
    United States
  • 9.3
    Scored 9.3
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 285 reviews
    I’ve been staying at this hotel for several years now. It’s very clean, rooms were just remodeled, quiet, best view, free breakfast that has plenty of options, very friendly staff, pool and hot tub were quiet and perfect temp. I would 100% recommend this hotel.
    Lynn
    United States
  • 9.2
    Scored 9.2
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 127 reviews
    this place was exceptional! staff was friendly, facilities were clean, pool indoor and outdoor, hot tub inside, in a quiet location but near everything you may want to do in sister bay. would definitely recommend staying here, and we will be back in the future!
    Linda
    United States
  • 8.6
    Scored 8.6
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 276 reviews
    Perfect location just a mile outside of Sister Bay main town. Excellent little hidden beach nearby as well. Friendly staff at check-in, with plenty for information on the area.
    Annette922
    United States
  • From ISK 31,448 per night
    8.8
    Scored 8.8
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 310 reviews
    It was good. I liked having it included in the price of our hotel booking. I would have liked a little more protein added, like boiled eggs or more cheeses.
    Deborah
    United States
  • 9.3
    Scored 9.3
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 285 reviews
    These apartments are super comfortable, quiet and clean. Beautiful views over Sister Bay which is 15 minutes walk away on the lake edge path. Helpful staff.
    Judy
    United Kingdom
  • 9.3
    Scored 9.3
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 285 reviews
    The location in Sister Bay is gorgeous. Our room with the waterview is beautiful. We loved the outdoor hot tub. The staff was very friendly.
    L
    Lisa
    United States
  • 8.6
    Scored 8.6
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 276 reviews
    The property is a short drive to Sister Bay and close to other sites and attractions. It also is nice to have the kitchenette.
    Gale
    United States
  • From ISK 31,448 per night
    8.8
    Scored 8.8
    Fabulous
    Rated fabulous
     · 310 reviews
    Loved the room, pool, hot tub, and location. Such a cute spot close to downtown Sister Bay.
    Olivia
    United States
  • 8.2
    Scored 8.2
    Very good
    Rated very good
     · 252 reviews
    Everything was good room, staff, just wrong time of year for us to visit Sister Bay
    Debra
    United States
  • 7.6
    Scored 7.6
    Good
    Rated good
     · 519 reviews
    The location near Sister Bay was good. The ease of reaching other places also good.
    D
    DEANN
    United States
  • 9.0
    Scored 9.0
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 5 reviews
    Great location, overlooking Sister Bay and the amenities (like a spa retreat)
    Kristina
    United States
  • 7.6
    Scored 7.6
    Good
    Rated good
     · 519 reviews
    The proximity to Sister Bay is extremely convenient.
    C
    Corbin
    United States
  • 9.3
    Scored 9.3
    Superb
    Rated superb
     · 25 reviews
    Newer hotel, clean, good location.
    Rodney
    United States